Book Review: Crossing by Stacey Wallace Benefiel

Posted July 17, 2013 by Stormy in Books / 3 Comments

Crossing

by Stacey Wallace Benefiel

Crossing

 Publication Date: May 8, 2013
Obtained Via: Was given e-arc in exchange for honest review by publisher on netgalley
Format Read In: Kindle e-book

Summary

via Goodreads:

Due to heavy subject matter, Crossing is recommended for readers 17+.

He stole her lipstick…and her heart.

Twenty-year-old Dani Walker can’t believe her luck when she’s paired up with the gorgeous Liam Garrett as her Acting I scene partner – or when he ends up in her bed. Being a Plain Jane with a mouth on her hasn’t exactly served Dani well in the guy department. In fact, she’s had nothing but one night stands. Still, she lets go of her insecurities and falls for Liam, despite feeling like he’s holding something back.

When Dani finally discovers Liam’s secret, she must learn the true meaning of accepting the ones we love for who they are, or risk losing the best thing that’s ever happened to her.

My-Review

So far, I have been wildly unimpressed with new adult books as a genre. I think it has potential, but I haven’t seen it. So when I saw this book with the stunning cover on Netgalley and I read reviews that said this wasn’t your typical New Adult book, I decided to branch out of my comfort zone and read it. And while I do agree that Crossing manages to duck some of the more troublesome trends in New Adult literature, it still plays into quite a few of them.

Dani is quite an interesting character. I can’t say that I LIKE her necessarily, but I’m interested in her actions and I’m at least drawn to her as a narrator. She’s loud and a bit obnoxious at times, but at least she’s not the stereotypical quiet, shy girl, so thumbs up there. Liam also gets an A- as a character, since he’s actually pretty endearing and not a jerk. Him and Dani have their misunderstandings and they both have less-than-stellar behavior at times, but as a couple, they treat each other pretty well, which is refreshing to see. Their relationship happens pretty quickly, so I’m not sure I buy it 100%, but at least they ACT like a normal couple towards each other.

Crossing also tackles some pretty heavy issues, especially towards the end. I won’t give anything away for fear of spoilers, but let’s say I was happy with how these issues were dealt with. Things weren’t perfect, but Dani handled things like a real person might, and the book tended to not be too dark nor too light(it’s not as light as the cover or the synopsis suggest, actually).

At this point, Crossing would be a solid 3 stars. Except(you knew it was coming), there are some things I just can’t ignore. Having just been a college student, Dani and Liam do not act like any college students I know. In fact they, and there friends, act older. I don’t find this “new” adult, because besides the fact they’re in college, they’re acting pretty much like adults.

And that’s not to say that college students aren’t mature(because I’d like to think most of us are), but college is quite transitional and I saw none of that here. Dani and Liam go out and party all the time, never have to do work, and never seem to have the typical college woes. At the beginning of the book, there’s a note that says Crossing was in part based on a true story, so perhaps this excessive life is some people’s college experience, but I never saw anyone have it to quite this extent. By all means, new adult books, show the parties and the dating culture and college culture because it is real, but be realistic. Besides theater rehearsals, Dani never seems to have class or have to work on assignments, and I just don’t understand this portrayal.

And as I said before, college is a time of transition as well. And Dani and Liam are older college students, so I don’t expect them to be homesick, but I just expect  a little more. . . questioning of themselves, I suppose. I’m not sure how to word it, but I just know that in college my roommates and friends and I had a lot of late night conversations about who we were, what we wanted to do, and how we’d fit into the world, and I don’t think this is something that was unique to us. And this happens a little bit, mainly with Liam, but it still just feels off to me. I don’t expect every college experience to be the same, but all the New Adult I’ve seen, read, and heard about has been an experience cut from the same cloth, and it’d be nice to see some variety.

Final Impression: Crossing manages to avoid some of the biggest downfalls, but unfortunately still gets stuck in a few areas. The portrayal of college experience seemed off to me, but I did enjoy Dani’s character. While I think Crossing is an example of some good steps to take in the New Adult genre, I don’t think it’s there yet.  2/5 cupcakes. 

2cupcakes

newsignature

2 Stars

Tags: ,


3 responses to “Book Review: Crossing by Stacey Wallace Benefiel

  1. I’ve had a similarly tumultuous experience with the “New Adult” genre. While I have no doubt that it has the potential to inspire some very important discussion, many of the books seem to be plagued by the same tired tropes. While I would love the opportunity to read more books set in college, I have to agree that most often the portrayals of college life are less-than-realistic, and certainly do not typify my post-secondary education experience. Far too often college simply seems to be used as a means of allowing the main characters to experience a greater degree of independence. We’re rarely treated to the quest for self discovery that I think so many college students are familiar with. I’m sorry that you weren’t able to enjoy this particular story more 🙁

    • stormydawnc

      Right. And I’m not AGAINST that greater degree of independence and it’s consequences, because that IS true for some college students. But I don’t want that to be ALL NA is. I want some REAL conversations, some REAL discovery, and yes, some REAL struggles.

  2. I’ve had very similar experiences with my limited foray into the “new adult” genre, and most reviews I’ve seen have said the same. The only “new adult” book I’ve read that does the genre justice is Lauren Graham’s Someday, Someday, Maybe. Franny’s internal monologue annoyed me a bit, but the novel deals with issues 20-year olds are facing in a realistic way.

Leave a Comment!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.